Does everyone love everyone? The psychology of iterative reasoning
نویسندگان
چکیده
When a quantified premise such as: Everyone loves anyone who loves someone, occurs with a premise such as: Anne loves Beth, it follows immediately that everyone loves Anne. It also follows that Carol loves Diane, where these two individuals are in the domain of discourse. According to the theory of mental models, this inference requires the quantified premise to be used again to update a model of specific individuals. The paper reports four experiments examining such iterative inferences. Experiment 1 confirmed that they are harder than immediate inferences. Experiment 2 extended the finding to negative inferences, i.e., granted that Anne does not love Beth, it follows from the quantified premise that Carol does not love Diane. Experiment 3 established that intermediate steps referring to specific individuals are accepted more readily than intermediate steps referring to quantified variables. Experiment 4 showed that the participants’ written justifications corroborated the model theory.
منابع مشابه
Game Theory with Translucent Players
A traditional assumption in game theory is that players are opaque to one another—if a player changes strategies, then this change in strategies does not affect the choice of other players’ strategies. In many situations this is an unrealistic assumption. We develop a framework for reasoning about games where the players may be translucent to one another; in particular, a player may believe tha...
متن کاملDefining the Integration of Faith and Learning
A Common Task The integration of faith and learning is not a process that is strange, quaint, unusual, or unique to Christianity. The integration of learning (or knowledge) is an activity performed by everyone who understands the need for a coherent worldview, by everyone who knows that believing conflicting claims is not reasonable. Further, if we understand by faith the set of basic beliefs...
متن کاملFuture study of Description System Architecture Approaches with Emphasis on Strategic Management
Systems Architecture is a generic discipline to handle objects (existing or to be created) called systems, in a way that supports reasoning about the structural properties of these objects. Systems Architecture is a response to the conceptual and practical difficulties of the description and the design of complex systems. Systems Architecture is a generic discipline to handle objects (existin...
متن کاملBook Review: How the Other Half Thinks: Adventures in Mathematical Reasoning and Mathematics Galore! Masterclasses, Workshops, and Team Projects in Mathematics and Its Applications, Volume 49, Number 8
How does it happen that there are people who do not understand mathematics? If mathematics invokes only the rules of logic, such as are accepted by all normal minds; if its evidence is based on principles common to all men, and that none could deny it without being mad, how does it come about that so many persons are here refractory?...[T]hat not everyone can understand mathematical reasoning w...
متن کاملMaintenance of Mental Health.
Everyone agrees that going to school is an important occasion in a child's intellectual life, but not everyone yet realizes that it is an equally important emotional occasion?that, mdeed, it may be considered a final stage in the process of weaning about which Miss Hay-Shaw wrote in the August issue of Mental Health. The young child has to learn that he may not depend upon his mother for all hi...
متن کامل